Hannah is catering Lisa's upcoming family reunion gathering, which will be held at the Murrayville Hall, home of Delores' theater troupe, the Murrayville Players. While she helps Hannah prepare, Lisa has to deal with her irresponsible out-of-town cousin Jennifer, who has always seemed to get into one predicament or another in her life. Hannah is also preparing for her first real date with Chad, she calling in Andrea for support. Amid these issues in Hannah's life, she, while making a delivery to a customer, discovers the dead body of said customer inside the customer's home, that customer who was Delores' fellow troupe member. Because of Delores' relationship with the victim, Sheriff Ealing places her on his suspect list, which masks what he would truly want at least until this case is solved. Because of Delores' predicament, Hannah launches her own investigation, which looks into the victim's varied unknown life beyond the Murrayville Players.